Bison Forum

BisonOline wrote: ↑Fri Apr 18, 2025 7:26 pm Look at the stats.

There you are BisonOline. No clear winner but I remember them all.

Receivers might have something to do with the passing yards. Vraa, McDonald lots of great names.

It’s so close it’s literally personal preference at this point. Good problem to have.

Carson is behind in every stat but one.Plus Stick won 3 championships , Carson 2. And one of those should have been sticks after he came in and won what 8-9 games in a row and Carson got the nod for the Natty. Plus to be truthful Id take Brock Jensen of Wentz as well.

Plus Im pretty sure Stick won more games than Wentz as well.

But lets be honest. This was just one of lakes trolls to get a reaction. It what he does and has done for years.

The BIG wins:

• Grambling -(1965 1st national championship) QB Jim Carlson

• Montana - QB Tony Stauss beats FCS Montana at Washington Griz. Stunning victory under new Head Coach Craig Bohl

• Central Michigan- Steve Walker big win over FBS conference champion

• Minnesota - QB Steve Walker (first win same season as Central Michigan)

• Kansas State - Brock Jensen

• Iowa - Stick

Walker may have led the best team.

Cam Miller lost to Colorado and AZ

Wins at KSU and Iowa were and are unbelievable.

If it’s big wins = best QB you first have to decide which win was biggest.

For me it’s Montana, Kansas State and Iowa. For my Dad it was Grambling.

Cam is a winner. He may not have had the best teams but he stood out to me as poised, great runner and passer. He got better and better and better. He has it all. The Bison may miss him next season.

Wentz won an nc game with the team on his back but a lot of memories of Wentz being great are actually memories of RJ being one of the greatest at his position as well.

Carson started two seasons, of course he's not up there in the stats.

He was also made of glass and missed time when he did play. Makes his statline even more impressive.

But Easton still wins out this conversation.